89737571
Central Texas College| Political Review One| Banner Desecration Amendment| Dr . Karen Waugh| Jamorion Stanford| 9/17/2012| Flag Desecration The American flag is among the most identifiable symbols the us has today. As children, we study in school to cross the heart with the right palm and recite the give your word of fidelity to the United States of America, while facing the flag, a beloved symbol.
Being a soldier in the usa Army, We proudly put on a flag as a part of my own Army Fight Uniform (ACU). It is donned by troops like me to demonstrate the love of country, honor and determination to this wonderful nation.
It can be cherished by simply veterans with fought in this country, and families of the fallen military cherish this because it is emblematic that their very own loved one lost their life for this nation. With all the superb things the American flag stands for from this country, wherever does the directly to desecrate this stand? Could it be indeed a form for a person or persons to express their particular right of freedom of speech by the First Variation, or an outright disrespect of a nationwide treasure that ought to be protected at any cost? If therefore , what are these costs? Flag desecration doesn’t come as a fairly easy choice.
One could think that this would be the case, but also in reality your decision is just not a straightforward. The decision simply by Congress upon whether to protect the banner from desecration is not that minimize and dry out. Many opinions must be taken into consideration when delving into this issue. On one aspect you have the supporters in whose arguments consist of, that burning up the flag dishonors American who fought against and perished for this country, the forty-nine states that have called for Congress to pass the Amendment, as well as the power taken form Congress to protect the flag by the Supreme Court in 1989, was incorrect and needs fixing.
The opposing team arguments suggest that passing this kind of Amendment could alter our nation’s background for the first time, there is not enough to justify making such a big change to a big part of the Initial Amendment, which flag using is exceptional. The next thing to perform is consider all the different level of landscapes. When an picture of the banner being desecrated is displayed, many of us whether you served in the armed service or certainly not, can’t help but feel disrespected. This kind of holds true intended for supporters of the Flag Desecration Amendments.
To get Americans whom fought and still fight for the us, an take action of desecrating the flag is a slap in the face towards the service they provide and the eschew they have built while serving. The flag is a national treasure not just a cloth with colors and stripes. It truly is symbol that stands for liberty and combines this country. Facilitates for the Flag Desecration Amendment firmly believe that these kinds of a national treasure must be upheld and backed by our elected representatives, so much so that 49 says have called to Congress asking the Flag Desecration Amendment be passed.
The Flag Desecration Amendment states, Congress shall have the power to prohibit the physical desecration of the flag of the United States. (How a Member Determines to Vote) The power to safeguard the flag is believed by followers to have been wrongfully taken from Congress by the Supreme Court in 1989. Passing the Flag Desecration Amendment would reverse that action, and protect the sacred mark. This modification is about repairing a independence to the people. The people’s independence to protect their very own flag, a freedom they enjoyed and exercised to get 100 years. Flag Burning Argument and Poll) Supporter’s factors of the proposed Amendment will be convincing, like those of Brooke Brown, a nine yr old, who published about the flag like a national cherish and that it should be protected, support even coming from a child are convincing, but there are always two sides to a story. Opposing team of the Flag Desecration Variation, propose reasons that make feeling in certainly not passing this kind of amendment and in doing so might lead to a great ultimate unfaithfulness of the freedoms granted to us by the First Amendment.
In completing the Banner Desecration Variation, it would signify if a person wanted to share political freedom of talk by desecrating the banner they wasn’t able to. A suggested Amendment could undermine the First Amendment. As Us citizens we are approved many liberties and the flexibility of presentation is a major one, therefore if congress were to say that a person could not go to town and to contain it in writing in that case what different would change. Opponents as well make a point that flag burning up is rare.
They say that may be doesn’t happen every year, but when it has it turned out to express political speech because the Supreme Court held in 1989. Oppositions also say that once freedoms such as this be taken away then simply what’s to express what more congress will regulate and subject to infractions. Anna Ross, form the “How a Member Determines to Vote module brings up, that while it might make all of us mad to find out our flag being desecrated, it is not suitable reason to weaken one of the most important principals of democracy.
The component simulation was very helpful, the how a member chooses to vote module displays the steps that are taken by a person in congress about voting intended for such an alteration. The process can be difficult, it takes a bit of personal beliefs and in addition being able to end up being objective and possess the rights of the people at heart. One must be open-minded rather than be put through by a single side. The excellent of all should be considered when taking a vote on the matter like the Flag Desecration Amendment.
Taking into consideration the thoughts and feeling of those for the amendment such as what it means to Americans who also serve to get the sign of the banner, the 49 states which have called for a change, and for the ones that think a choice needs to be fixed, while not forgetting that having a passage comes a history changing change, since a desecration action is definitely not a prevalent everyday occurrence, and that there is not enough to justify shorting the liberties given to People in america through the Initially Amendment.
No one likes to start to see the symbol of your nation, one that unites all of us being damage, it is not just a piece of textile with hues on it, nevertheless a symbol that stands for flexibility. The component shows how difficult a task this can be to attempt and personal beliefs and public interest may conflict, so it goes without saying, do we protect our symbol whilst upholding the First Modification? I found that initially I had been for the Flag Desecration Amendment, it ought to be protected, but since I deemed all the opinions presented astonishingly, I found that we voted NAY.
I thought, even though I proudly wear a flag on my ACUs, the flag was not the freedom itself but symbolic. The first amendment funds freedoms and to vote for the Flag Desecration Amendment, would take a specific freedom apart. Although We fight for the us, this country can be not the flag on its own, it is a sign, but what that stands for is definitely the many liberties granted in which I believe will be the bigger picture.
The combination of these points as a whole need to be deemed by congressmen and women when ever casting a vote on this difficult subject, one need to take into account all points and avoid let her or his own views be the sole means on what to political election. Works Mentioned Flag Burning up Debate, Politics Debates and Polls Discussion board, September 17, 2012, http://www. youdebate. com/DEBATES/FLAG_BURNING. HTM The Center on Our elected representatives at Indiana University and work the “How a part Votes” module, September seventeen, 2012, http://congress. indiana. edu/interactive-learning-modules, Central Texas College Blackboard
