comparing and contrasting sonnet 130 and ars
“Change what you discover by changing how you see” (Huie). This quote relates to “Sonnet 140, ” by simply William Shakespeare and “Ars Poetica, ” by simply Archibald Apple pc Leish. Sonnet 130 is all about the faults of his mistress, although realizes right at the end of the composition, that his love is all that matters. This man would not see his mistress as an unpleasant woman, nevertheless instead observed her as someone who he loves dearly. In another way, Ars Poetica states that “a poem should not mean, but be” (MacLeish 23).
People who go through a poem may make an effort to interpret the real which means, but there really is nothing to understand. A composition should just suggest what it says. Although the two “Sonnet 130, ” simply by William Shakespeare and “Ars Poetica, “by Archibald MacLeish have similar styles such as simpleness, and related devices just like using imagery to describe natural beauty and characteristics, they have distinct meanings, since one poem seems to anticipate a considerable amount by a mistress, and the additional poem wants nothing of your poem.
A single similarity between “Sonnet 130” and “Ars Poetica” is definitely their styles of looking nothing but simpleness in a poem and a mistress (stated in the last couplet), and love and devoutness. When examining “Sonnet 130” one may think that this man usually spends his time complaining about his mistress, and clearly dosen’t love her, however , at the conclusion of the poem he understands that his mistress will not be beautiful, however love can be beautiful, and that is all that matters. “And yet, by simply heaven, I do believe my love as rare” (Shakespeare 13). In “Ars Poetica, ” MacLeish explains that “a composition should be wordless” (7) and “a poem should be motionless in time” (9). One might be baffled by what the poem is in fact trying to declare, but he ended the poem simply by saying, “a poem should never mean, yet be” (23), which was a clearer declaration.
As was said just before, a composition is certainly not something persons should above analyze, it may just make you feel the way it will. Almost ove a piece of art or statue, a poem is not just a puzzle, but a feelings or a sense. Both poetry seem to have different views on what to anticipate from a mistress/poem. In “Sonnet 145, ” William shakespeare expects significant amounts of things coming from his mistress. There are 14 lines discussing the frustration of his mistress’ eye, lips, hair, cheeks, breathing, voice, and exactly how she walks. Lines including her eye “are not like the sun” (Shakespeare 1), her lip area are less reddish than coral, and her hairs are like black wire connections growing on her behalf head, display how low he is for these less attractive qualities. “Ars Poetica” is very different in this manner. MacLeish says, “A poem should be palpable and mute” (1), and “Dumb while old medallions to the thumb” (3).
These types of words illustrate how he believes that poetry must be different than what society expects them to become. He wishes nothing of your poem, but just thinks that poems should be whatsoever they want to be. Another likeness between “Sonnet 130” and “Ars Poetica” would be that they both make use of imagery to compare beauty and nature. “Sonnet 130” used this product, to demonstrate the size of beauty through imagery. “I have seen tulips damask’d, white and red, but simply no such tulips see My spouse and i in her cheeks” (Shakespeare 5). This compares his mistress’ face to the splendor of a went up.
“Ars Poetica” has many lines that use images, one of which usually compares terms to the airline flight of parrots, “a poem should be wordless as the flight of birds” (MacLeish 7). Equally writers do an impeccable work using imagery to enhance the readers understanding and use descriptive words to make the poem more beautiful and interesting sounding. “Ars Poetica” and “Sonnet 130” are similar in the way that they can both have an identical theme of ease and love. “Ars Poetica” wanting a poem have it’s simplest terms and wanting that to indicate only just what says.
Although in “Sonnet 130” Shakespeare does apparently expect a whole lot from a mistress, this individual states at the end of the poem, that this individual wants just the mistress he features. Another similarity is that they equally compare splendor and mother nature. This device was used purely to entice you, and help to make it easier for the reader to understand. One particular essential big difference between both equally poems, can be that in “Ars Poetica, the poet person strongly believes that a composition should be “wordless” and simple, almost careless. Nevertheless , in “Sonnet 130, ” Shakespeare consumes most of the poem taking about his mistress’ unattractive characteristics and appears quite expecting of a volume of things. Studying these important similarities and differences happen to be what help the reader be familiar with poem in a more analyitical way.
you
