We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Film “Gothika” Essay

In the the year 2003 film “Gothika” Halle Fruit plays a psychiatrist who have loses her memory and wakes up in an insane asylum, the same 1 where she had recently been an employee physician.

She’s confused, discombobulated and provides lost period. Pete, a psychiatrist enjoyed by Robert Downey Junior., is the doctor assigned to her care and Doug, her husband, had been the doctor in charge of the facility. Miranda, Berry’s character, at some point learns that her partner has been killed and that this wounderful woman has been arrested and recharged with his killing (Kassovitz, 2003). From the very beginning, the movie pretends to mindset right. Nevertheless unfortunately, it truly is largely merely pretending.

The first issue in the movie takes place with the information of Miranda’s psychotic break and the activities leading to this. The doctors caring for Miranda argue that her mental disease resulted via her accident, not vice versa. At first, his or her explain her illness like a traumatic stupor brought on by the horror of murdering her husband. Or, they claim, the stupor might be associated with the head personal injury from the vehicle accident and not related to her mental condition.

Her doctor likewise asks her about medicines that your woman may have taken to cause the violence (killing her husband) or her sleepwalking. While it is appropriate to be concerned about a drug-related cause for amnesia (Merck, 2007) it is silly to believe that those involved in her treatment will not have conducted blood assessments to find drug employ prior to the questioning. The movie lets us know Miranda continues to be out of touch with her mind for three days and nights when your woman awakens in the asylum, and so the mere proven fact that they would not have conducted bloodstream tests and enjoying the results again by then seems implausible.

Another major problem the movie makes in its characterization of Miranda’s mental condition and treatment is that Pete is given to do her evaluation. Although it can be asserted that in certain areas he might be the sole doctor offered, as one is usually dead and another offender of the murder, the story arrived before the truth of treatment standards in the movie. It seems as though Berry’s character can even recognize this kind of as the lady tries to get a handle on her romantic relationship with Pete, asking him if they had an affair or perhaps wanted to have one (Kassovitz, 2003).

This right away calls in to question the ethics of the doctor plus the accuracy of any judgment he makes regarding her condition. The film then simply tries to befuddle the viewer with the question of whether Miranda is suffering some sort of psychotic break ro is truly being haunted by ghosts. From a diagnostic point of view, Miranda’s symptoms include the catch when the girl was confessed, her loss in memory, and finally, though the girl with loathe to admit this to her doctor, seeing and hearing her “ghost”. (Kassovitz, 2003). The film even goes as long as to have Miranda address her hallucination, stating “: I actually am a rational person.

I believe in science. My spouse and i don’t have confidence in the paranormal, and I don’t believe in ghosts. But if you are the ghosting of Rachel Parsons, can you let me out of this cellular? ” (Kassovitz, 2003).

The pros, upon ability to hear her adventure of viewing ghosts, maneuver right from a diagnosis of disturbing amnesia into a diagnosis of schizophrenia, skipping right part delusional. This is not exact in the least. First, there is Miranda’s statement relating to her interaction with the ghost.

She is continue to logical enough to know that interaction which has a ghost is usually unreasonable and generally accepted being a mental disorder. “Schizophrenia is definitely characterized by psychosis (loss of contact with reality), hallucinations (false perceptions), delusions (false beliefs), disorganized conversation and behavior, flattened have an effect on (restricted range of emotions), intellectual deficits (impaired reasoning and problem solving), and work-related and cultural dysfunction. ” (Merck, 2007) If your woman were schizophrenic, it is less likely that she’d have retained her reasonable mind enough to realize that she had been illogical. The truth that her educated mind could continue to identify her behaviors while irrational is one of the clearest indications that the girl was not affected by the intellectual deficits linked to schizophrenia.

Next, there is the appearance of the ghosting herself. If Miranda’s delusions had been restricted to fleeting images or auditory hallucinations, her symptoms might have been consistent with schizophrenia. Nevertheless , the presence of an identifiable visual hallucination the actual illness more in line with the symptoms of delusional disorders than schizophrenia (Allpsych, 2007). “A delusion can be described as belief that is clearly bogus and that signifies an furor in the affected person’s content material of believed.

The false belief is not made up by the person’s cultural or religious history or his or her level of intelligence. The key feature of a delusion is the level to which anyone is certain that the belief is true. A person using a delusion will host firmly towards the belief in spite of evidence towards the contrary. Delusions can be challenging to distinguish coming from overvalued suggestions, which are irrational ideas that the person contains, but the sufferer has by least a few level of hesitation as to it is truthfulness. A person which has a delusion is completely convinced the delusion is real. ” (Mind Disorders, 2007).

To be honest that if Miranda was suffering from either of these mental disorders, her symptoms would have 1) been more extreme in the case of schizophrenia or 2) come with a total belief in her misconception. She would will no longer question if ghosts had been real. The last implied associated with the film is that Miranda has been battling abuse as a result of a sadistic and manipulative serial great who as well happens to be her husband.

After the ghost prospects Miranda with her husband’s torture and maltreatment chamber, the viewer is definitely left with the impression that Miranda’s mental illness including the delusion of seeing the ghost was her mind’s way of working with the menace from her husband and having strong enough to manage his mistreatment. This is full and complete Hollywood passage. While it can be done for battered woman to lose control and kill her husband in times where your woman fears for her life, Miranda’s symptoms will be completely away of sync with the typical description of BWS (McElroy, 2002).

Probably, this was an effort by the writer to attract sympathy pertaining to the character that did, actually kill her husband. If the movie had intended to show mental health issues in an appropriate fashion, just would have to end with the evident ghost story. The problem was that the writer wanted to create a story in which a ghost utilized to explain away mental condition or a mental illness was sued to describe away a great encounter with the supernatural.

No matter what, they failed. By demonstrating the viewer the ghosting, the viewers does not issue Miranda’s state of mind. After all, we’ve seen it too. To be more in tune with the analysis they were probably going for, schizophrenia, the movie needs to have relied on an unseen presence and presented perfectly fair explanations for things that happen, my spouse and i. e. display Pete leaving her cellular unlocked in order that she an escape and perform her exploration.

As it is, the film falls flat as a ghost story and fails being a psychological thriller. Had that been carried out properly, it might have prevailed at both equally. WORKS MENTIONED “Delusions”, Nov 18, 3 years ago.

Kassovitz, Mathieu (Director) and Sebastian Guitierrez (Writer). “Gothika”. USA: Columbia Pictures, the year 2003. McElroy, Wendy. “Battered Women’s Syndrome: Research or Scam? ” The Independent Institute, October 28, 2002< http://www. independent. org/aboutus/person_detail. asp? id=488>November 18, 2007. “Prognosis and Treatment”November 19, 2007.

Psychotic Disorders< http://allpsych. com/disorders/psychotic/index. html>, November 18, 3 years ago.

< Prev post Next post >