menace ii society man behavior study paper
Research from Study Paper:
The question that Caine challenges with is actually life provides any real meaning, considering the unsightly, cruel, but still unimaginably unpredictable circumstances beneath which so many people are able to live – “in particular, young black men caught within a web of presumption and prejudice about their alleged naturel and the actual might be capable of – becomes the essential question” (Flory 2008) pertaining to Caine and for the entire film.
environmental perspective. Less than half an hour into the Risk II World, Caine’s grand daddy asks him if he even cares for you if he lives or perhaps dies. This kind of question is a philosophical theme, as suggested by Camus, but it is additionally a emotional question since what happens every time a person becomes ambivalent about their life? And what drives them to turn into so? There may be some recommendation that centering on race by delineating what sort of presumed remorse of African-Americans and other related conditions (e. g. relatives, drugs, avenue life, and so forth ) might force these to think a certain way as well as force all of them into making certain choices which may not only break down them nevertheless that they discover difficult to steer clear of (Flory 2008). It is important once analyzing Caine’s character that we now have many extraneous factors in the case other than typical psychosocial stage elements to consider. Because Caine is growing in a tough element of Los Angeles that is certainly more or less limited to itself, he is stuck in an area in which black men make poor choices since his intelligence of options is limited (2008). There is a kind of resistance to escape where he is usually from is we are to trust Moody-Adams’s hypotheses about the effects of such morals on the psyches of small black People in the usa (2008).
“Each man cell phone calls barbarism no matter what is not his own practice. We now have no different test of truth and reason compared to the example and pattern with the opinions and customs in the country we live in” (Montaigne 1958; Moody-Adams 2002). This quotation of Montaigne’s, written in the sixteenth century, is an astute observation that reminds that relativism about differing practices can be not an entirely new development. Anti-relativists mistakenly try to put morality beyond culture, instead, relativism is sensible of our intuitions about the limited mindset reach of the moral procedures (Harman 1975; Moody-Adams 2002). What’s more is the fact it “makes no impression to ask if an action is wrong, aside from its regards to a group’s implicit agreement to accept certain moral rules (1975; 2002).
Applying the tenets of environmental psychology to understand Caine’s character is considered the most natural way to make feeling of the story of his life. When living at home with his grandpa and grandma and going to school full-time, Caine was able to focus on his studies and other aspects of existence without sense lured by or taken into the assault of south L. A. street your life. However , when out of faculty, the street sucked him in – certainly not because he was so convinced but because of the environmental stress that was put on him by his peers wonderful surroundings. His grandparents are not able to quit the effect once it had gotten to him. Young, dark males in American “negotiate their everyday lives beneath the ‘shadow of whiteness'” (Carroll 1998).
The moment Caine observed the film it’s a Wonderful Life along with his grandparents, he looked at the screen and saw almost nothing that linked to his experience in life – even though at that time he was coping with a supportive couple of grandparents who were faith based and secure in their take pleasure in for him. Caine felt the color line in America and he almost certainly thought that his grandparents had been ignoring that. How otherwise could they blissfully enjoy a white colored family rejoice as a great angel restored their delight? Could it be that Caine, even after a hundred years of captivity being removed, still seems unwanted and neglected in society? Can it be that most from the males roaming the roads with him feel the same?
Looking at Caine from an environmental psychology standpoint allows us to see that Caine is a item of his environment. He was not the first (his legacy was that) and he will not be the past. While which chance that Caine could have overcome his fate, there is the greater chance that he wouldn’t – and this individual didn’t.
We all have been products of the environments. Which reason that people who will be abused while children have got a greater probability of becoming abusers themselves. it’s the question between nature versus nurture, but when we’re getting nurtured in all the wrong ways, it’ll often win. We are a result of each of our experiences. it is quite human to oversimplify the challenge, wanting to invest of our efforts into the answer. While character could hardly ever be discounted, traits would be the direct cause of the discussion of a lot of genes which might be influenced by simply our environment. Without having too much into nature or nurture, the point is that all of the boys in Menace 2 Society are products of their environment. Their particular motives seem to be arbitrary, vicious and almost usually dominant, however it is this dominance, this arbitrariness that is intricately associated with their oppression towards the more dominating world – that which can be rich, that which is white-colored. These men avoid put worth on a human life, not even their own.
Nuisance II World seems to need the audience to believe that Caine is definitely not a killer – even though he killers, but rather, the film wants us to believe that Caine is a patient of his society fantastic environment. Caine can be comprehended in zero other method, which is why the movie is so resoundingly interesting, particularly when it comes to Caine’s character (although all the character types have interesting aspects that can do with a psychological prodding).
cognitive point of view. From a cognitive internal standpoint, we could look at Caine and try to understand his mental processes – how he thinks, how he interprets. it’d be interesting to determine what Caine remembers regarding his life before he went to experience his grandpa and grandma. To learn more about the effects of his existence with his parents would be very useful in a better understanding of Caine as a whole person. it can not sufficient to simply declare Caine is a product of his environment. While the environment is certainly significant when it comes to looking at a person’s psychological state, it is additionally important to know how they cope in that environment. What leads them to specific decisions and never others? Intended for Caine, he previously the most severe of one community and the most of another, why was this individual compelled by the other? One that would mean his life would end much too early?
Caine’s inner life is more important than his actions are because what this individual does comes out of what this individual thinks – of his life, of himself, of his universe. From what we see in the film, Caine appears to be a moral and overall very good person who definitely seems to be a victim of his environment; but , merely saying that he is a victim is actually easy. The viewers notice that he is not only a victim completely, but though he is performing horrible items, we feel sad to get him because we think that if this individual weren’t because situation, he would be fine. This is what is very brilliant regarding Caine as being a character in the film. Folks are not dark or light in the way the act and react. What compels to lure Caine to do what he will is a mixture of what he has seen, what this individual knows, in which he feels his most comfortable and, ultimately, how he views his your life in the bigger picture of the world. This has more regarding how he sees his race and how he sees his prospects.
Going back to the film 2 weeks . Wonderful Lifestyle, the Barnes brothers likely couldn’t include picked a much more ironic film to put in their own film. The very occurrence of Jimmy Stewart for the reason that environment – a small community where everybody knows everyone, likes you everyone, feels like a different world that was undeniably the complete point of its cameo. It is important that we all, as registrants of psychology, check out people not just as a part of the earth they are in, but we should look at the portion of the world that they can be not in; only then simply can we understand their authentic plight is obviously. The character of Caine in Menace II Society, got he were living, could have taught us a lot about the workings of circumstances within the mind.
References
Banks Gregerson, Mary. (2009) the cinematic mirror for psychology and life training.
Springer; 1st edition.
Carroll, Grace. (1998) Environmental stress and African-Americans. Praeger.
Erikson, Erik L. (1994) Identification and the existence cycle.
Flory, Dan. (2008) Philosophy
