Critical Analysis of the US Electoral College Essay
Electoral College is a term that refers to a selected band of representatives who have perform the work of choosing candidates to get particular effective offices just like presidents or church frontrunners. The selection process of electing individuals usually consists of participants by different and competing politics or faith based entities.
Recently, the Electoral College have been conspicuously applied in electing the Director of the United Stats as well as the Pope of the Catholic House of worship. It is the US Electoral University that has particularly drawn much concern as to its performance and dependability in choosing the leader of the government republic. This essay pinpoints some of the concerns associated with the Electoral College and analyses the implications from the suggested adjustments and alternatives.
Analysis in the US Electoral College In the usa, the Electoral College method is used to choose the Leader from competitive candidates via either the Republican Get together, the Democratic Party of independent prospects. Rather than decide a director and a vice-president immediately through countrywide elections, the united states conducts individual elections in its 51 claims during which the winner in each condition is allotted the number of electoral votes proportional to the total representation with the state in Congress with a total of 538 electoral voters. The winner of the presidential contests is supposed to win a total of 270 votes with the Electoral College.
Although the style of the Electoral College was clever and well intentioned, the system is susceptible to inherent flaws, many of which were fixed by constitutional amendments although some remain unresolved to date (Miller, 2008). Certainly, as Burns (2008) noted, the selection system established by the Electoral College has in its core the objective to engender fairness inside the election of candidates in nonpartisan environment, the objective was made irrelevant with the formation of competing political parties to compete in the selection process to get the presidency.
There is no doubt the Electoral School system reveals many issues and complications to the fairness of the Presidential election in america which include the challenge of election reversal, difficulties with the voting power, partisan biasness, excessive focus on battleground states and the likelihood of promise violations. 1 obvious difficulty that comes forth from the Electoral College system is that the results of accumulated the total electoral votes in the states may become different from adding up the total well-known votes in all those says. Miller (2008) identifies the specific situation of the 2000 elections the place that the eventual victor, George T. had even more electoral ballots but significantly less popular have your vote than the loss, Albert Gore.
Moreover, when there emerges a serious 3rd party contestant, it would be difficult for any candidate to garner the mandatory 270 electoral votes. According to the US constitution, the emergence of such an probability would require that the political election process be taken to the Our elected representatives where voting should be conducted repeatedly right up until a victor emerges. While there are worries if the Electoral College represents adequate share of voting powers to all or any the claims, there are also problems as two whether the bipartisanship of the two-party system in america is likely to symbolize nonpartisan political election of the director.
Moreover, the focus of the Electoral College on the battleground declares attracts excessive attention via parties and the candidates, efficiently raising questions on the voting powers of the other states. Realization Some of the recommended proposals advised include: (1) amending the constitution to empower the American with all the constitutional privileges to straight elect the president through a popular election; (2) apportionment of the electoral votes fractionally according to the population of says so as to get rid of the problem of election change; and (3) equal apportionment of the electoral votes to all or any states to remove the problem of state voting powers.
The proposal to amend the constitution in order to give American the constitutional rights to directly decide the chief executive stands out as the most superior advice because it is going to eliminate all the problems and challenges associated with the Electoral School. References Miller, N. R. (2008). The united states electoral university: Origins, change, problems and prospects.
UMBC, retrieved about 22 May well 2009 by:
